Damnatio Memoriae and the Modern Effort to Erase Exceptionalism: From Caracalla and Geta to Cancel Culture and Corporate Algorithms

I always stop for the new issue of Biblical Archaeology Review. They publish only a few times a year, and I have been looking forward to the Winter 2026 edition. Inside it, or in the advertising that came with it, there was a notice for a Museum of the Bible exhibit on the Byzantine Empire—and an ancient Rome story that caught my attention immediately. The Rome article pointed to a familiar pattern: an emperor facing the problem of legacy, succession, and what happens when one son decides the other must disappear so that he can rule alone. The surviving brother murders the other and then sets out to erase every trace of him—paintings, sculptures, inscriptions, public memory. The goal is not merely to kill a rival but to make it as if the rival never existed.¹

That practice has a name that later historians gave it: damnatio memoriae, the condemnation of memory. The most famous and thorough Roman example is Caracalla’s treatment of his brother Geta. After their father Septimius Severus died in 211 AD, the two brothers were supposed to rule jointly. Caracalla had Geta murdered (reportedly in their mother’s presence) and then ordered a systematic campaign to remove Geta from the record. Faces were scraped from portraits. The famous Severan Tondo shows the imperial family with Geta’s face deliberately obliterated. Names were chiseled out of inscriptions. Coins were recalled or defaced. Even speaking the name became dangerous. The violence of the erasure is still visible today; the blank spaces draw the eye more than any intact portrait could.²

The Ancient Method and Its Modern Form

I have seen versions of this method up close for a long time. It is not new. In biblical history and in the records of ancient empires, people who wanted power have repeatedly tried to murder a rival and then erase the evidence of that rival’s existence so that their own claim looks cleaner. What struck me in the BAR material and the Museum of the Bible advertisement was how clearly the same impulse appears in modern left-wing politics and in the communist tradition. The goal is not simply to defeat an opponent in open argument. It is to remove the opponent from public memory so that the desired narrative can stand alone.

Communist regimes in the twentieth century and the present Chinese system have practiced versions of this. History is rewritten. Figures who do not fit the current line are removed from textbooks, monuments, and public discussion. In the West, the softer version is called cancel culture. It seeks to make a person a non-person: unemployable, unpublishable, algorithmically invisible. The techniques differ—social media campaigns, institutional pressure, corporate compliance, platform suppression—but the purpose is the same as Caracalla’s: clear the field so that the remaining power looks natural and unchallenged.

Hollywood, China, and the Box Office Reports I Used to Hear

I remember listening to WLW in the mornings around 2010–2012. Every Monday there was a box-office report from the theaters. I paid attention to the overseas numbers, especially China. Studios were desperate to get films into that market. The rules were strict. Content had to be adjusted. Certain themes, characters, or portrayals were unacceptable if you wanted access. Domestic box-office numbers were announced, but the real pressure often came from the Chinese share. Studios learned that playing by those rules was the price of entry. Over time, that pressure affected what got made, how stories were told, and which cultural signals were allowed to remain.

The same pattern appeared in other industries. Aerospace, automotive, and manufacturing companies adjusted practices, supply chains, and internal culture to maintain access or avoid friction with Chinese partners and regulators. The argument was usually commercial: the market is too large to ignore. The cost was gradually adopting methods that treat independent or exceptional voices as problems to be managed rather than assets to be protected. I watched that process for years. It was not always dramatic. It was often quiet compliance that slowly narrowed what could be said or built inside the company.

Platforms, Algorithms, and Soft Erasure

I have experienced the modern version directly. On YouTube and similar platforms, the algorithm decides visibility. Content that fits certain preferred narratives—identity-focused, progressive in the current institutional sense—receives promotion. Material that questions those narratives, or that pursues different subjects, does not. I have posted videos for years. The views that matter most often come when people find the work through other channels (the blog, direct links, word of mouth) rather than through algorithmic recommendation. Offers to “boost” numbers for a fee exist; they are a scam layered on top of a system that already sorts visibility according to non-transparent criteria.

This is not the same as a Roman emperor ordering statues smashed. It is slower and more deniable. A creator can keep posting and still become functionally invisible to the majority of potential viewers. The result is similar in effect: the space for certain kinds of argument or personality shrinks. People who notice the pattern and refuse to adjust their output pay a visibility tax—those who adapt to what the system rewards grow. The selection pressure favors conformity over the kind of independent exceptionalism that used to be more common in American cultural and industrial life.

Corporate Adoption and the Attack on Exceptionalism

Too many American corporations imported elements of this control culture. Human-resources departments, compliance regimes, and external pressure from large institutional investors or government partners created environments in which deviation from approved language or priorities carried career risk. Manufacturing and technical industries felt it as well. The explicit goal was often described in terms of inclusion or risk management. The practical effect was to reduce the space for people who operated outside conventional boxes, questioned prevailing assumptions, or produced results that did not fit the preferred narrative.

Communism and its softer socialist variants have long treated exceptional individual performance as a problem. If success remains visible and unpunished, it undermines the claim that outcomes are primarily the product of systems rather than differences in ability, effort, or judgment. Erasure—whether by violence, by institutional exclusion, or by algorithmic demotion—serves to protect the preferred story. In ancient Rome, it protected a brother’s claim to sole power. In modern institutions, it protects a managerial or ideological claim that certain kinds of people and certain kinds of results should not be allowed to stand out.

I have been outside the conventional box for most of my working life. That position made the pattern easier to see. When you are not dependent on the approval of the group enforcing the current line, you notice how often the first move against a rival or dissenter is not argument but removal from the conversation. The Roman example in the BAR material and the Museum of the Bible advertisement is useful because it is old, documented, and visually obvious. The scraped face on the Severan Tondo still testifies to the attempt. Modern versions are less physical but no less intentional.

What Remains Visible

History shows that complete erasure is difficult. Coins stay in circulation. Fragments of inscriptions survive. People remember. Digital platforms create new records even while they suppress others. The attempt itself often becomes the most durable evidence. Caracalla’s campaign against Geta’s memory is better known today because of the blanks he left behind than it would have been if he had ignored his brother.

The same dynamic operates now. Efforts to make certain voices or certain historical facts disappear tend to draw attention to the effort. Readers of Biblical Archaeology Review and visitors to the Museum of the Bible can see the ancient pattern clearly. Anyone paying attention to media, corporate culture, and platform governance can see the modern continuation. The method is old. The tools have been updated. The underlying desire—to clear rivals and inconvenient evidence so that one narrative can rule without competition—has not changed.

I recommend the Museum of the Bible exhibit if the timing works. The artifacts and the historical record make the point more effectively than any contemporary argument. The Winter 2026 Biblical Archaeology Review continues a publication I have read for decades because it keeps the longer record available. That longer record is the best defense against any temporary success at erasure.

Footnotes

1.  The specific advertisement or article in the Winter 2026 Biblical Archaeology Review referenced a Museum of the Bible exhibit touching on Empire and Roman succession struggles. The historical pattern described matches well-documented cases of political murder followed by memory sanctions.

2.  The clearest surviving visual evidence is the Severan Tondo (c. 200 AD), a painted wooden panel showing Septimius Severus, Julia Domna, Caracalla, and the deliberately erased face of Geta. Parallel erasures appear on the Arch of the Argentarii and in numerous inscriptions and coins. Ancient sources (Cassius Dio and others) record the murder and the subsequent purge. Modern scholarship treats this as one of the most thorough applications of what later writers called damnatio memoriae.

3.  Hollywood’s adjustments for the Chinese market in the 2000s–2010s are documented in contemporary trade reporting and later analyses of content changes required for theatrical release and co-production.

4.  Platform ranking systems and their effects on political or culturally non-conforming content have been described by creators, researchers, and, in some cases, internal documents released through litigation or leaks. The precise weighting remains non-public.

5.  Corporate adoption of speech and conduct codes influenced by external activist or state pressure accelerated in the 2010s; measurable effects on hiring, promotion, and internal expression have been reported across multiple industries.

Bibliography for Further Reading

• Biblical Archaeology Review, Winter 2026 (and the long run of the magazine for comparative ancient Near Eastern and classical material).

•  Museum of the Bible current and recent exhibits touching on Empire, Rome, and the transmission of texts and images.

•  Cassius Dio, Roman History (accounts of the Severan succession and Geta’s death).

•  Historia Augusta (later and less reliable, but part of the traditional source base).

•  Scholarly treatments of damnatio memoriae: Eric R. Varner, Mutilation and Transformation: Damnatio Memoriae and Roman Imperial Portraiture; Harriet I. Flower, The Art of Forgetting: Disgrace and Oblivion in Roman Political Culture.

•  The Severan Tondo (Altes Museum, Berlin) and related epigraphic evidence from the Arch of the Argentarii and provincial inscriptions.

•  Contemporary reporting on Hollywood and the Chinese theatrical market (Variety, Hollywood Reporter, and later academic or journalistic retrospectives).

•  Analyses of platform content moderation and ranking (various technical and policy papers; creator testimonies).

•  Studies of corporate speech codes and institutional capture in U.S. industry during the 2010s–2020s.

•  Comparative work on historical memory sanctions from ancient Egypt (Akhenaten) through twentieth-century totalitarian regimes.

The Roman evidence is physical and still visible. The modern evidence is institutional and algorithmic. Both reward attention to what was removed and why. I have watched the pattern long enough to recognize it when it appears in a museum advertisement or in a platform’s recommendation engine. The older record remains the clearest teacher.

Rich Hoffman

More about me

Click Here to Protect Yourself with Second Call Defense https://www.secondcalldefense.org/?affiliate=20707

About the Author: Rich Hoffman

Rich Hoffman is an author, political consultant, and strategic advisor based in Cincinnati, Ohio, and the creator of The Politics of Heaven—a unique framework that connects biblical theology, ancient history, and modern power structures to explain how moral alignment and spiritual forces shape global events. Blending real-world political experience with deep research into archaeology, UFO phenomena, and suppressed historical narratives, Hoffman offers compelling commentary on topics ranging from ancient civilizations and the Dead Sea Scrolls to modern populist movements, paranormal continuity, and leadership strategy in chaotic environments. As the author of The Gunfighter’s Guide to Business and the forthcoming Politics of Heaven, he brings a grounded yet provocative voice to media discussions, supported by firsthand experiences and a cross-disciplinary approach that bridges science, history, and theology. For interviews, speaking engagements, or expert analysis, visit richhoffmanbooks.com or contact directly by email at rhoffman@richhoffmanbooks.com.  If you’ve seen the movie, Disclosure Day and want to talk about it and the implications of Presidnet Trump’s UAP disclosures, let me know and we can bring some color to your coverage. https://richhoffmanbooks.com/media-inquiries-broadcast-topics-and-contact-info/?frame-nonce=ad51e7ecba I do have a firsthand UFO encounter to discuss.